The process of getting a prescription filled can be surprisingly complex, and increasingly, patients are facing delays and denials due to a requirement known as prior authorization. This involves insurance companies demanding a doctor’s justification before approving a medication or treatment. While intended to control costs and ensure appropriate care, prior authorization is becoming a significant burden for both patients, and physicians.
Jaclyn Mayo of Lunenburg, Massachusetts, experienced this firsthand. Diagnosed with multiple sclerosis, an autoimmune disease affecting the nervous system, Mayo found relief from debilitating balance issues with a medication called Zepbound, initially prescribed to aid weight loss – a strategy to reduce stress on her joints. “It was really helping me,” she said. “I could go up and down stairs and not feel like I was going to fall.” Beyond improved mobility, the medication also alleviated other MS symptoms, improving her sleep and reducing numbness in her hands. After seven months of successful treatment, her pharmacy unexpectedly refused to refill her prescription, citing a lapse in prior authorization.
Mayo’s experience highlights a frustrating reality: even for medications that have previously been approved, insurance companies often require re-authorization after a certain period. She was left navigating a complex system, contacting her pharmacist, doctor’s office, and her insurance company, only to discover the need for a new approval process. “Why do I need a prior authorization for something that I am already prior authorized to take? If my doctor says that they want me on a medication, why does my insurance have another say in that?” she questioned.
Why Insurers Utilize Prior Authorization
Insurance companies maintain that prior authorization is a necessary tool to manage healthcare costs and ensure patients receive evidence-based care. However, the process is often criticized for being opaque and administratively burdensome. The American Medical Association (AMA) has voiced concerns about the complexity and delays caused by prior authorizations, stating they create significant hurdles for physicians and disrupt patient care. A recent poll revealed that one in three insured adults consider prior authorizations a “major burden” when accessing healthcare.
The increased scrutiny often targets newer or more expensive medications, like GLP-1s such as Zepbound, but can also apply to lower-cost generics. This suggests that cost is a primary driver of the requirement, but the specific criteria for prior authorization remain unclear, even to healthcare providers.
Navigating the Prior Authorization Process
To minimize disruptions and ensure timely access to necessary medications, several steps can be taken:
- Know Your Expiration Date: Prior authorizations don’t last indefinitely. Contact your insurance company or pharmacy benefit manager to determine when your current authorization expires.
- Don’t Delay: Initiate the prior authorization process well before your medication runs out. Allow ample time for potential delays or complications.
- Request Expedited Review: If your health is declining or you are experiencing significant discomfort while waiting for approval, ask your doctor to request an expedited review. Federal regulations now require expedited decisions within 72 hours for certain requests.
- Explore Alternatives: Discuss alternative treatment options with your doctor. Your insurance plan’s formulary – the list of covered medications – may have different requirements for different drugs.
- Appeal Denials: If your prior authorization is denied, don’t hesitate to appeal the decision. Approximately half of appeals are successful, particularly when supported by detailed medical documentation.
Submitting a comprehensive appeal with supporting documentation, including evidence of prior treatments that were unsuccessful, can significantly increase your chances of approval.
The challenges faced by patients like Jaclyn Mayo underscore the need for greater transparency and standardization in the prior authorization process. While intended to safeguard healthcare resources, the current system often creates unnecessary obstacles for those seeking essential medical care.
Health Care Helpline helps you navigate the health system hurdles between you and good care. Send us your tricky question and we may tap a policy sleuth to puzzle it out. Share your story. The crowdsourced project is a joint production of NPR and KFF Health News. KFF Health News is a national newsroom that produces in-depth journalism about health issues and is one of the core operating programs at KFF.
